Offering and receiving feedback necessitates mutual respect. While opinions on the optimal delivery style may vary, a supportive approach is generally most effective. It is important to remember that we are all human beings, and many artists invest their hearts and souls into their work. Scribes in the SCA are rarely acknowledged, almost never reimbursed for materials, and their time is often undervalued. Therefore, it is crucial to be kind for the sake of kindness.
Giving
- How to Offer Advice
Obtain permission to ensure the artist is receptive to feedback. Distinguish between a critique and criticism. Ask questions to understand their goals and visions. Just because an option exists doesn’t mean it should be shared.
Be specific about areas like color, shadow, or composition, not general statements like “I like it” or “fix it.” Art is meant to evoke a response, so specificity helps convey what’s liked and what could be improved. Use “I” statements to express your feelings, as this makes comments more palatable. If a comment starts or ends with an apology, reconsider whether it’s appropriate.
Express feelings about the artwork using “I” statements, not absolute rules. There’s a proper way to address someone else’s work.
Respect the artist’s intent by asking about their primary goal before suggesting changes. Never assume a project or artist’s objective. Many artists simply enjoy sharing their work.
Receiving
- How to Receive Advice
To understand someone’s observation, ask clarifying questions. If a comment is unclear, ask for clarification. Clear communication is helpful in such situations.
When filtering feedback, keep only what aligns with the creative vision and discard the rest. The artist chooses what’s suitable for their project. This involves deliberate choices, and not all feedback is valuable.
Stay objective and avoid personal attacks. Separate yourself worth from the artwork. This can be challenging and requires detachment.
Lizzies Scribal Project 